After years of staring at “Coming Soon” pages and dissecting every frame of every trailer, we finally stepped into the silk-strewn kingdom of Pharloom. For many of us, the Hollow Knight game wasn’t just a masterpiece; it was a home. But returning to this world via Silksong has felt less like a warm welcome and more like a trial by fire.
Where the first game version allowed us a slow, melancholic crawl to find our footing, Silksong demands we hit the ground running at a breakneck pace, immediately testing our muscle memory with enemies that are faster, smarter and far more lethal. A massive debate has erupted across Reddit and gaming hubs, centered on a single, stinging question: Has Team Cherry crossed the line from a challenging dance into unnecessary punishment?
For some, the new Silksong difficulty is a natural evolution that respects the veteran status of its players. For others, the frequent “double damage” and grueling runbacks feel like a wall designed to filter out anyone who isn’t a top-tier speed runner. The community is effectively split between those who view Pharloom as a masterclass in high-stakes action and those who feel the series has traded its soul for a stronger gauntlet.
The Dance of Combat: Hornet vs. The Knight
The first thing you notice in Pharloom is the speed. If the original Knight was a sturdy tractor, deliberate and grounded. Hornet is a Ferrari. She zips, parries, and heals with a grace that makes the old gameplay feel almost sluggish.
However, the Silksong difficulty isn’t just about faster reflexes; it’s about a smarter, meaner world. Enemies in Silksong are always reacting and waiting for their turn to be hit and hunted. Based on the community’s early stats and boss patterns, the input reading on specific encounters makes it feel like the AI is living inside your head, predicting your heals before you even press the button.
The Walk of Shame: The Controversy of Runbacks
While we all love a good boss fight, the punishment often manifests in what gamers call the walk of shame. Unlike the modern convenience of Elden Ring’s Stakes of Marika, Silksong doubles down on its roots.
The now-infamous “Last Judge” boss has become a focal point for this frustration. It’s not just that the boss is hard; it’s the five-minute trek through hazardous terrain just to get back to the arena.
The Double Damage Dilemma
Perhaps the most shocking change is the double damage philosophy. In the original game, losing two masks was a terrifying late-game threat reserved for elite bosses. In Pharloom, this jump in Silksong difficulty happens almost immediately.
Team Cherry’s logic seems to be that because Hornet can heal three masks instantly (Bind), she needs to take more damage to stay vulnerable. But for players still learning the ropes, this creates a binary health system.
The Problem: If you have five masks and take two damage per hit, you are effectively dead in three mistakes.
The Result: This “front-loaded” Silksong difficulty acts as a filter, potentially pushing away players before they can appreciate the mid-game brilliance.
Tools of the Trade: Learning to Play in The Silksong Way
If you’re struggling, the solution might not be your reflexes, but your strategy. The consensus among those who have conquered the early game is simple: Stop playing it like the first game.
The needle is just the beginning. Silksong is designed around Hornet’s expanded toolkit. Players who embrace the crests and tools find that the punishment begins to fade. Someone would argue about it, the game is hard but they are convinced to use nothing but the needle. The moment we got the Harpoon, we felt like an overpowered god.
As the adrenaline finally fades after a grueling three-hour session, there is a certain peace in the post-game ritual. You lean back, perhaps catching the ambient glow of Hollow Knight resin wood with night light, and realize that the click moment in Silksong is a reward unlike any other in gaming.
Conclusion: A Masterpiece or A Challenger’s Dream?
In conclusion, is Silksong difficulty overtuned? The truth is, it demands total mastery. It’s a game that expects you to have already graduated from the first title. It doesn’t want to hold your hand; it wants to see if you can fly.
Pharloom is a brutal, beautiful, and uncompromising evolution. While the runbacks might be tedious and the double damage might feel like a cheap shot, there is no denying the “flow” state is more satisfying than ever.
What do you think? Does the difficulty make the victory sweeter, or are the runbacks ruining the experience for you? Let’s talk about it in the comments.